Jen ([info]jennylin) wrote,
@ 2008-05-09 08:39:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Current mood: contemplative
Current music: #1 Crush-Garbage
Entry tags:childhood, event, lunch, mda

My first MDA event
 As I said in my last post, I went to my first local MDA event yesterday. It was in many ways a bizarre event for me personally, though all in all not a bad experience by a long ways. It was a fundraiser for the local MDA called "Locked Up" where volunteers are put in a mock jail and people take pictures of them, and people coming through the event pledge money to "bail them out" at whatever level the volunteer decides to set their bail. It was a clever idea, and made for cute pictures and what seemed to be a good time for the volunteers. The volunteers also seem to be treated very well, getting free lunch and lots of other swag for their troubles. There was an amazing amount of volunteers and people attending such a local event. It must've taken up almost half of the restaurant. My PCA and I were treated in a friendly manner, and some of the people even assumed that I was a volunteer and not a "client". It probably helped that my PCA that day was a friendly, outgoing person as I tend to not be in crowds of people, but I actually ended up talking to a mother of a 10-year-old with Duchenne's muscular dystrophy. She thought that I was much younger than I was (I admittedly have a baby face) and was shocked when I told her that I was married, but I didn't feel disrespected or dehumanized in any way.


Mostly what I struggled with when I was sitting there surrounded by all of the MDA literature was feeling conflicted and confused. I was flooded at times with feelings that seem petulant now when I was looking at the pictures of children at the MDA summer camps. I felt bitter for never having a community of people that I could relate to that way when I was a child. Having been undiagnosed my whole childhood meant that I could never be involved with summer camps without my family around because I couldn't take care of myself independently, but could never be involved in special needs summer camps or other such events because I didn't have a label put on my disability that most of those organizations required. Frequently I was the only person in a wheelchair at any school I ever went to. That was, at times, an extremely lonely place to be. What I felt growing up at most times was completely invisible. Like I was just a consciousness floating around that nobody ever knew was there.

Another thing that I struggled with was that they mentioned the telethon on literally every piece of literature on the table. I know that the telethon makes the MDA an enormous amount of money that they actually do very good things with, so I am not surprised that to them it is a very good thing. But the damage done by how people with disabilities are portrayed on the telethon is something that I have experienced myself. Depending on people pitying people with disabilities in order to raise money is very sad. I know that it works and that it does good things in the end, but the damage it does to public perception of our community is horrific. Seeing that mentioned on every piece of literature was a slight slap in the face every time. That is something that I will need to come to terms with if I intend to attend further events, which I likely will. I will likely not bring up my feelings to others there unless the topic is already brought up or if I am asked directly, but it is something that I have to keep in mind.


(Post a new comment)


[info]noss
2008-05-09 11:00 pm UTC (link)
It's interesting to hear your feelings about the telethon. It seems to be an issue for all of the non-profits I have volunteered with, whether they were addressing hunger, homelessness, animal issues, whatever. Any time you have a group of people that are disenfranchised by the system, there is this conflict between trying to make things better immediately (charity) versus trying to change the system itself, which is of course much more difficult. And usually the charitable efforts get in the way to an extent, because they make people feel like they're solving the problem when really, while it's true that money helps in the short run, it helps fund this system of dependence and in a way makes it more difficult for the group getting charity to achieve empowerment.

Sorry if I'm coming off as didactic. My classes this quarter have focused a lot on institutionalized racism and this kind of touched on that for me. I've been thinking a lot about what is the role of someone who wants to change things for a group they are not a part of? As a white person, what is my role in promoting racial equity? As a non-disabled person, what is my role in promoting equal accessibility and such issues? What contributions enhance empowerment and which ones detract from it? I would love to hear any thoughts you have about it. :)

Also - I miss you! This summer I won't have class, but I'll still have a funky work schedule that will probably leave me lots of free time in the middle of the week and at generally odd hours. Let's hang out, it's been way too long.

(Reply to this)(Thread)


[info]francisb
2008-05-10 06:32 am UTC (link)
Thank you for placing this extremely touchy issue into a broader context. I think that in some situations there is also another factor.
There is a tremendous sense of power and positive self-worth gained by helping the down trodden. There is nothing bad about feeling good because you help somebody. There is something very wrong with promoting their vulnerability and helplessness in order to maintain a one up position. Way too many disability organizations I have had contact with over the years suffer from this problem. I am totally blind and spent a number of years on the board of our local blindness center. The fund raising had many similar qualities to the telethon, on a less soffisticated scale. In the time I attended board meetings, I
not once was able to get hold of board materials ahead of time in a form I could read, and was repeatedly chastised for asking that documents be read aloud.
I think the way one addresses these issues is by taking care that those who are the subjects of the fund raising are also in charge of the process. This does not mean a few token repreprensatives, it means for real. The way I think those not in a category can assist is to support this kind of structure.
I do not mean that those who are not subjects of the charity should be excluded, nor their views ignored. I do mean insuring that the disenfranchised are placed in charge of their own fates.

I like your comparison to institutionalized racism, I spent some time studying that in years gone by, and find many parallels.

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]jennylin
2008-05-10 09:52 pm UTC (link)
I concur with this statement for the most part, except for when you're talking about animals which you had mentioned. Clearly they cannot talk for themselves! And I don't think they really care what you do as long as they get snuggles and food.*laugh*

When dealing with the disability community, it is very important to involve people with disabilities. Especially people with disabilities who are interested in independence and overall betterment of their life and situation. This is not always easy for your average, able-bodied person as you may not have a lot of experience with how to involve people who might need special accommodations or communicate in a different way. It is very important to talk to people with disabilities, and really listen to what they tell you of their opinion and their needs. So frequently people ask our opinions about what we need, and then immediately refute what we say or not even listen to what we say at all, either because they think that meeting our need is impossible before even looking into it or because they think they know better for some unknown reason. I think the most popular way of looking at people with disabilities in our society is very much how people might look at a child who has opinions but may not know what it actually needs. Most people don't know that meeting accommodations is actually not as hard as they might think if they just looked into how to do it. Most people don't even bother. The important thing here I think is to really listen, or find ways to listen to as many different opinions of people in any given group to understand as much as you can. Also, realize that each individual is different than a group and has individual opinions and needs so never give up on listening even if you think you know.

Also, I will be posting your comment to our community for other people (mostly women) to answer your questions. That should probably give you more of a breadth of opinions and knowledge in regards to at least the disability part of this question. Thank you very much for asking by the way! You have no idea how rare it is to even hear this from someone else.

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)


[info]noss
2008-05-12 06:09 pm UTC (link)
LOL, yeah, the animal situation is not really the same. Although, you do still have the conflict between fighting the problem at a cosmetic or charitable level versus trying to really attack the problem at its heart.

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]jennylin
2008-05-10 10:43 pm UTC (link)
Oh, and in regards to getting together, sure! Now that I have reliable help again we could meet for lunch or something someday (though I would have my attendant in tow, but she is cool). I might be busy for the next couple weeks getting life back in order after not having help for a couple weeks, but e-mail me your schedule and I'll let you know where mine overlaps.:) You still working over on this side of the hill? (It is funny how we still ask that question even though we moved to a different state!)

(Reply to this)(Parent)

changing things for groups we are not part of
[info]3kitties
2008-05-11 10:44 pm UTC (link)
I like your questions. (I am in seminary, and in some of my classes we have been exploring similar questions.) For me, as a person with disabilities, the best change tends to occur at the individual level, when I've made some kind of connection with someone from that "other group." That other person is then in a position to help with advocacy because they have a very personal knowledge of why I'm asking for things, or an emotional connection and reaction to things that happen to me.

I don't know how to bring some of this individual connectedness into group intervention, but I think it matters.

(Reply to this)(Parent)


Create an Account
Forgot your login?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…